This Week's Drop Will Be Revealed On Thursday

Each drop pairs one of our classic Pieluck flavors with one special limited time flavor.
Join the Lucky List and we'll text you right when the drop opens. We can only make so many pies each week so this will be your best chance at getting a pie before they're sold out.

JOIN THE LUCKY LIST

HOW TO GET LUCKY

  • 01 — JOIN THE LUCKY LIST

    We’ll text you right when Thursday’s drop opens, with the flavors of the week and a link to order.

  • 02 — PICK YOUR PIE

    Choose between one Pieluck classic and one limited time special, or just get both. Pre-order before that week’s pies are claimed.

  • 03 — WE BAKE

    We bake every order fresh on Friday and Saturday, just in time for the weekend.

  • 04 — WE DELIVER

    Local deliveries go out Saturday and Sunday, straight to your door.
JOIN THE LUCKY LIST

WE HAVE A THING ABOUT PIE.

Pie should be the dessert everyone hopes you brought.

We make the pies we want to eat: familiar flavors made more interesting, big flavor, thoughtful textures, and crusts worth eating all by themselves.

Some weeks we stay close to the classics. Some weeks we get adventerous. Either way, every flavor has to earn its place in the drop.

If it isn't worth saving room for, it isn't ready.

Our Classic Flavors

THE ONE THAT STARTED IT

Key Lime Pie

Zesty lime filling, perfectly balanced sweetness, on a buttery graham cracker crust. This is the flavor that kicked the whole Lucky List thing off.

RICH, SMOOTH, NO NOTES

Chocolate Cream Pie

Silky chocolate filling in a chocolate cookie crust, finished with whipped cream. Deep, rich, and built for sharing (though we won't tell if you don't).

ISLAND VIBES, NO PASSPORT NEEDED

Coconut Cream Pie

Creamy coconut filling in a buttery shortbread and macadamia nut crust, finished with whipped cream and toasted coconut. Tastes like a vacation you didn't have to plan.

A HOUSE CLASSIC

Apple Pie

Classic Dutch-style apple pie: juicy, tart, cinnamon-kissed apples nestled in our oat cookie crust. Cozy comfort, no notes.

Past Weekly Flavors

This pie will knock your socks off! 

Banana Cream Pie

The most requested pie!  Silky custard meets fresh banana slices, all nestled in a buttery vanilla wafer cookie crust and topped with clouds of our signature vanilla bean whipped cream. It's the dessert that turns ordinary moments into memorable ones. An elevated classic!!

An ode to one of our favorite Valentines treats!

Chocolate Covered Strawberry Pie

This pie is lushious!  The perfect combination of fresh and rich!  Our best-selling rich chocolate pie with a Valentines twist - she has a chocolate cookie crust, chocolate custard, and a *fresh* strawberry filling.  

Our limited edition pie for the holiday season! 

Pretzel Chocolate Caramel Pie

This pie has everything we dream of during the holiday season - the balance of salty sweet, creamy and crunchy.  She highly anticipated for a reason!

A FAMILY CLASSIC, MINUS THE NUTS.

Bumpy Road Bars

Our twist on Grandma’s rocky road bars: a fudgy cream cheese brownie studded with chocolate chips, piled high with toasted marshmallows, and finished with a drizzle of chocolate frosting. We left out the nuts. Turns out, that was the move.

YES, WE EAT THE CRUST.

Every crust is made from scratch, and it changes with the pie. Graham cracker under the Key Lime, an oat cookie crust for the Apple, buttery shortbread and macadamia for the Coconut Cream. No pre-made shells, no shortcuts. It's dessert, not an afterthought.

DON'T LEAVE YOUR PIE TO LUCK.

The Lucky List gets first access to every weekly drop, before it's public. No spam, just pie, and first dibs when it counts.

JOIN THE LUCKY LIST